My Sister-in-Law Stole My Wedding Centerpieces. She Didn't Know the Vases Were Rented.
Fiction. This is an original, made-up story: names, characters and events are invented, and any resemblance to real people or events is coincidental.
Part 2 of 5 · Chapters 3–4 of 10
Listen to Part 2 · 4 min
Chapter 3
I drove to Tessa's house the next morning, the sunlight feeling too bright for my mood. When I walked through her front door, I didn't even have to ask. The living room had been transformed. The twelve centerpieces were perfectly spaced across her coffee tables and sideboards, the white peonies glowing against her beige walls.
Tessa was there, holding her phone aloft, circling a vase to capture the perfect angle for her followers. She didn't even look up when I entered.
'Tessa, give them back. Now,' I said. I tried to keep my voice steady, but it trembled slightly.
She finally lowered the phone and looked at me with a bored expression. 'Sylvia, really? You're coming over here to haggle over some flowers? They were basically gifts. You didn't want them, and I can actually make them look good.'
'They aren't yours to take!' I countered. 'I told you they were rentals. They belong to a company, and they have to be returned.'
Tessa let out a sharp, mocking laugh that echoed in the room. She stepped closer, her presence designed to intimidate. 'Please. You've always been the little mouse of the family. You're just territorial because you're stressed. These vases look far more 'at home' here than they did in that sterile ballroom.'
She turned back to her phone, ignoring me entirely as she typed a caption. 'See? This is why I love family,' she muttered, likely referring to her 'generous' sister-in-law. 'They just give me the best things.'
I felt that familiar sting—the sensation of being invisible even while standing right in front of someone. For a second, I considered just leaving, letting the conflict fade into the background as I always did. But then I remembered the contract. I remembered Sterling's face—the stern, uncompromising look of a man who didn't believe in 'family favors.'
Chapter 4
Gideon arrived twenty minutes later, looking exhausted. He walked into the living room, looked at the stolen vases, and sighed. He didn't look angry; he looked defeated.
'Tessa, just give them back to Sylvia,' Gideon said, though his tone lacked any real authority. 'It's not worth the drama.'
Tessa spun around, her face instantly shifting into a mask of wounded innocence. 'Drama? Gideon, I'm shocked! Sylvia is acting like I committed a felony over some decor. She's being completely territorial over things she didn't even buy. Is this how your marriage starts? With accusations and demands?'
Gideon looked at me, his eyes pleading. 'Sylvia, can't we just... let it go? She'll return them eventually. I don't want our first week as a married couple to be spent in a family war. Just let it slide for a few days.'
My stomach churned. It wasn't that Gideon didn't love me; it was that he was terrified of his sister's tantrums. He had spent thirty years navigating her emotional minefields, and his instinct was always to clear the path by sacrificing the quietest person in the room.
'I can't let it go, Gideon,' I said, my voice growing firmer. 'They aren't ours. We don't own them.'
'They're just vases!' Tessa snapped, her voice returning to its sharp, commanding edge. 'Stop being so dramatic, Sylvia. Go home, take a nap, and stop trying to control everything. You're not the boss of me.'
She walked away to the kitchen, leaving me standing in the center of her living room, surrounded by stolen beauty. I looked at Gideon, and for the first time, I didn't see a protector. I saw another person who expected me to be the one to suffer in silence for the sake of 'peace.'
Coming up in Part 3“My phone vibrated in my pocket. It was Sterling from Velvet & Vine. I stepped onto the porch to answer,…”