Mystery & Creepy

The 1964 Polaroid in the Guest Room

Fiction. This is an original, made-up story: names, characters and events are invented, and any resemblance to real people or events is coincidental.

Part 3 of 3 · Chapters 5–6 of 6

Listen to Part 3 · 2 min

Chapter 5

I leaned closer to the mirror. The reflection showed the guest room, but it was different. The walls were pink. The chipped nightstand was there. And sitting on the edge of the bed was a girl. She looked exactly like I did at six years old, wearing the same blue pinafore I remembered from a faded memory.

She wasn't moving. She was staring directly at me, her eyes wide and knowing. I reached out to touch the glass, and my fingers didn't hit a hard surface. Instead, the mirror felt like cold water. My hand slipped through the silver surface, and I felt a small, furry object press against my palm. I pulled back instinctively, gasping for air, and looked down. In my hand was the stuffed rabbit, smelling of old dust and lavender.

Chapter 6

The rabbit was real, but as I held it, I noticed something tucked into its stitching. It was a small piece of parchment with a handwritten note: 'Thank you for bringing me home, Sarah.'

I looked back at the mirror, but the image had changed. The pink room was gone. Now, it showed the guest room exactly as it was today, but with one difference: there was a woman standing behind my reflection. She was old, with the same looping script of the diary written as a tattoo on her wrist. She smiled, a gentle, sad expression, and slowly raised a finger to her lips. Then, she stepped backward and vanished into the gray wall, leaving me alone in the silence of the house, holding a toy I had lost thirty-six years ago.