Family Drama

The Pewter Truth of Wrenwood

Fiction. This is an original, made-up story: names, characters and events are invented, and any resemblance to real people or events is coincidental.

Part 4 of 5 · Chapters 7–8 of 9

Listen to Part 4 · 5 min

Chapter 7

The document was a bombshell. The first will had been a decoy, a test of greed and observation. This second will was the truth.

'My dear Sloane and Sterling,' the letter began, written in Grandmother's elegant, looping script. 'If you are reading this, it means you have looked past the glitter of the silver to find the substance beneath. For years, I watched you both chase the wrong things—status, approval, and wealth.'

Sterling gripped the edge of the desk, his fingers digging into the wood. I continued reading, my voice trembling.

'The fortune you believe exists—the trust funds, the investments, the legendary Wrenwood wealth—is gone. I have spent the last fifteen years quietly funding the Wrenwood Scholarship for Underprivileged Youth. Every penny of the family's liquid assets has been transferred to a permanent endowment. I chose to invest in the future of strangers rather than the vanity of my own blood.'

Sterling let out a sound that was halfway between a laugh and a sob. 'She spent it? All of it?'

'There is one thing remaining,' I read, the final paragraph bringing us back to the present. 'The estate and the house. They are left to you both, jointly. You may sell them and split the proceeds, or you may maintain the home as a sanctuary. But know this: the house is only worth something if you are both in it.'

We stared at the paper. The 'most prized' teaset had been a vessel for a truth that stripped us of our expected windfall. We weren't millionaires. We were just two cousins in a drafty house with a fake pewter pot and a massive amount of debt between us.

'She played us,' Sterling whispered, sinking into the chair. 'She played us for fools.'

'No,' I said, looking at the handwriting. 'She gave us exactly what we needed. She stopped us from fighting over money that didn't exist.'

But the victory felt hollow. I still had my debts, and Sterling still had a lifestyle he couldn't afford on a lawyer's salary alone. We were left with a sprawling, expensive-to-maintain Victorian mansion and a choice that would define the rest of our lives.

Chapter 8

For three days, the house was silent. We lived in separate wings, avoiding each other as we calculated our options. Sterling spent hours on his laptop, researching the legal loopholes to challenge the second will.

'We could sue the endowment,' Sterling argued on the fourth morning, his voice strained. 'If we can prove she wasn't in her right mind when she signed the second will, we can reclaim the funds. We could save the scholarship's money and still have enough to live comfortably.'

I looked at him, seeing the ghost of the boy who always had to be first. 'And destroy the education of hundreds of kids? Just so you can keep your charcoal suits?'

'It's our birthright, Sloane!'

'Our birthright is this house, Sterling. And the truth.' I held up the fake teaset. 'She didn't want us to have the money. She wanted us to have each other. Do you honestly think she didn't know exactly what she was doing?'

Sterling looked away, his gaze landing on a framed photo of Grandmother on the mantel. She was smiling in the photo, a mischievous glint in her eye that I had never noticed before. He stayed silent for a long time, the only sound the ticking of the grandfather clock.

'I'm broke, Sloane,' he admitted, his voice barely a whisper. 'The firm is great, but my debts are worse. I've been pretending for years.'

I felt a sudden kinship with him. The 'perfect' cousin was just as fractured as the 'rebellious' one. I reached out and touched his shoulder.

'We can sell the house,' I suggested. 'We split the money, pay off our debts, and let the scholarship continue. We don't have to be the villains of this story.'

Sterling looked at me, and for the first time in a decade, he didn't see a nuisance. He saw a partner. He nodded slowly, a tension leaving his shoulders. We spent the afternoon signing the waivers, formally accepting the second will and the end of our financial fantasies.

Coming up in Part 5“Six months later, the Wrenwood estate was sold to a local land trust to be turned into a nature preserve.…”