Future

What If Hoover Dam Stopped Working in July 2030?

Speculative fiction · Alternate history. Characters, documents and events in this story are imagined; real people, places and institutions appear only as historical backdrop.

Part 3 of 4 · Chapters 5–6 of 7

Listen to Part 3 · 3 min

Chapter 5

American water law was written in 1922, when the Colorado River was having a historic flood decade. The negotiators assumed the river flowed at twenty million acre-feet a year. It has not done that in twenty years. The average now is closer to twelve.

When Hoover stopped, that century-old fantasy collapsed.

By July 26, California filed an emergency injunction against Arizona and Nevada, demanding its senior rights under the 1922 Compact. California's Imperial Irrigation District, which grows eighty percent of America's winter lettuce, argued it had priority from 1901. Arizona argued that was suicide. Tribes — thirty tribes hold legal rights to nearly a quarter of the river — entered the courtroom and reminded everyone that their rights predate the states by centuries.

The Supreme Court, on August 1, invoked original jurisdiction and froze all allocations. For the first time, the federal government had to decide who gets to be a desert city and who does not.

Justice Jackson asked a simple question that no lawyer could answer: How do you apportion zero?

If the law says there is water that is not there, who breaks first, the law or the people?

Chapter 6

They tried to make the dam work again. Engineers are optimists by training.

Within a week, the Bureau of Reclamation floated Operation Low Flow: drill four new tunnels through the canyon walls, forty feet below the original intakes, at elevation 820 feet, at a cost of 2.8 billion dollars. Even if Congress funded it instantly, it would take four years of blasting in 120°F rock. And at 820 feet, Lake Mead would be a puddle twenty-two miles long, holding only four percent of its original volume.

In Boulder City, I watched a crew lower a submersible pump the size of a school bus into the reservoir, a temporary fix to push a trickle over the dam. It wheezed. It pumped 500 cubic feet per second, compared to the river's normal 12,000. It looked like putting a straw into a drying ocean.

Others suggested something more radical. Decommission Hoover. Let the water find its old channel, blow the lower plugs, and let Lake Mead become a river again to deliver faster, with less evaporation.

A dam built to symbolize that man conquers nature was being asked to surrender for man to survive.

Is failure still failure if you choose it on purpose?

Coming up in Part 4“Today, June of 2031, Hoover Dam is still there. It has not crumbled. Tourists still take selfies, but now against…”