Mystery & Creepy

The Third Slice of Cherry Pie at Silver Lake

Fiction. This is an original, made-up story: names, characters and events are invented, and any resemblance to real people or events is coincidental.

Part 2 of 3 · Chapters 3–4 of 6

Listen to Part 2 · 3 min

Chapter 3

I shouldn't have gone, but the rain had stopped and the curiosity was an itch I had to scratch. Miller Road was a winding stretch of gray asphalt flanked by overgrown oaks. The house was a Victorian wreck, its white paint peeling like sunburnt skin. A 'For Sale' sign had fallen over in the mud, half-buried by autumn leaves.

As I stepped onto the porch, the wood groaned under my sneakers. The air smelled of damp earth and something sweet, like rotting apples. The front door was unlocked, swinging open with a slow, rhythmic creak. Inside, the house was frozen in time. A crochet doily sat on a side table; a half-finished crossword puzzle lay on the coffee table, the ink faded to a ghostly brown.

I walked into the dining room and stopped dead. There, on a dusty mahogany table, were two place settings. Two plates, two forks, and two glasses of water that had long since evaporated, leaving white mineral rings. But there was a third spot. A third plate was missing, leaving a clean, circular void in the dust of the tablecloth.

Chapter 4

The following Sunday, I approached Mr. Abernathy with a trembling hand. I didn't tell him about the house, but I asked about Clara. He looked up at me, his pale blue eyes clouding over. For the first time, he didn't smile.

'Clara didn't leave,' he whispered, his voice sounding like dry leaves scraping pavement. 'She just stopped being visible. We had a deal, you see. A way to keep the conversation going even when the clock stopped.'

He reached into his pocket and pulled out a small, tarnished silver bell. He placed it on the table and rang it once. The sound was sharp, cutting through the diner's chatter. Suddenly, the temperature in the booth dropped. I felt a sudden, icy draft brush past my arm, and for a split second, I saw it—a shimmer in the air, a distortion like heat rising off a highway in July.

'She says you're too curious for your own good, Maya,' Mr. Abernathy said, looking not at me, but at the empty seat. He then slid the third slice of pie toward me. 'Eat. You look thin.'

Coming up in Part 3“I couldn't eat. I spent the next week obsessing over the 'deal' he mentioned. I went back to the archives,…”