Family Drama

The Unsent Letter in the Sewing Machine

Fiction. This is an original, made-up story: names, characters and events are invented, and any resemblance to real people or events is coincidental.

Part 3 of 5 · Chapters 5–6 of 9

Listen to Part 3 · 4 min

Chapter 5

"What are you doing, Mom?"

Caleb didn't even say hello. He walked straight to the kitchen table and saw the printouts of Lydia's life scattered across the mahogany. He picked one up, his brow furrowing.

"Who is this woman? Why are you looking into someone from Maine?"

I didn't hide it. I handed him the letter. "You have a half-aunt, Caleb. Or at least, I have a sister. Grandma had a daughter she gave up in '74."

Caleb's reaction wasn't shock. It was irritation. He dropped the letter back on the table as if it were contaminated.

"This is an obsession, Mom. A curiosity. Why on earth would you want to dig this up now?"

"Because it's the truth," I whispered.

"The truth doesn't pay the taxes on this estate," Caleb snapped. "Grandmother was a respected woman. This town looks up to the Haskins name. If word gets out that she abandoned a child, it tarnishes everything. It complicates the sale. It turns a clean transaction into a scandal."

I looked at my son—the lawyer, the pragmatist. He was so much like Estelle. He valued the facade over the flesh.

"She's a human being, Caleb. Not a complication."

"She's a stranger," he countered. "And you're a widow who needs to move into a smaller place. Let the past stay buried. It's easier for everyone."

He left the room, but his words lingered like a stain. For a moment, I hesitated. I thought about the quiet life I had led, the safety of the lie.

But then I looked at the blue key. I realized that the only thing more terrifying than the truth was the possibility of spending the rest of my life being a curated version of myself. I didn't call Caleb back. I finished the call to Maine.

Chapter 6

The diner in Fairhaven was small, smelling of burnt coffee and salt air. I sat in a vinyl booth, my palms sweating. I had told Lydia who I was in a long, trembling email. She had agreed to meet, though her tone had been guarded, almost cold.

When she walked through the door, the air seemed to leave the room.

She was wearing a paint-stained smock, her graying hair pulled back in a messy knot. She looked exactly like the woman I saw in the mirror every morning, only her eyes were harder, etched with a lifelong suspicion.

We sat in silence for a long time. The only sound was the clink of silverware from the next table.

"You look like her," Lydia said. Her voice was raspy, stripped of the polish that had defined the Haskins women.

"I do?" I asked.

"The jawline. The way you hold your shoulders. You look like a woman who spent her whole life trying not to make a mistake."

I flinched. "I didn't know about you. I found a letter. She never mailed it."

Lydia let out a short, bitter laugh. "She mailed some. For the first few years, I got letters. Every few months, a card or a note. But they weren't letters of love, June. They were tests."

I frowned. "Tests?"

"She would ask about my grades. My behavior. My 'moral standing.' It was as if she was auditing me from a distance, checking to see if I had turned into something 'shameful.' And the moment I failed—the moment I mentioned I wanted to paint instead of go to nursing school—the letters stopped. Completely."

I reached across the table to touch her hand, but she pulled away. The distance between us wasn't just miles; it was a canyon of resentment that Estelle had spent decades digging.

"I don't want your apology," Lydia said. "I want to know why she thought she had the right to judge me from a pedestal of lies."

Coming up in Part 4“The drive back to Georgia was a blur of highway lines and heartache. I couldn't stop thinking about Lydia's eyes.…”