Mystery & Creepy

The Empty Fourth Chair of Cedar Hollow

Fiction. This is an original, made-up story: names, characters and events are invented, and any resemblance to real people or events is coincidental.

Part 2 of 5 · Chapters 3–4 of 10

Listen to Part 2 · 5 min

Chapter 3

The next day, I encountered Douglas Garrison. He was a reclusive carpenter with skin like cured leather and hands scarred by decades of chisels and saws. He was repairing a banister in the church foyer when I approached him.

"The corn bread," I whispered, glancing around to ensure Rosemary wasn't lurking. "Who puts it there?"

Douglas stopped sawing. He didn't look at me, but his voice was a low, gravelly warning. "That chair isn't for a guest, boy. It's for a debt. Some things in Cedar Hollow aren't meant to be archived. If I were you, I'd pack my bags and drive north before the leaves fully turn."

"A debt? What kind of debt?" I asked, my chest tightening as my pulse quickened.

Douglas finally looked at me, his eyes clouded with cataracts but filled with a genuine, raw fear. "The kind that doesn't go away with an apology. Just stay away from the basement."

Intrigued and stubborn, I spent the evening scouring the local historical society's digital files. I found a scanned photograph from 1954—a family of four standing in front of the very same community hall. The father, mother, and two children were dressed in their Sunday best. However, the face of the eldest daughter had been violently scratched out of the photo, leaving only a jagged white void where her smile should have been.

I checked my watch. 11:10 PM. I felt a sudden, irrational urge to check the locks on my windows. I remembered the way the corn bread smelled—honey and butter. It was a specific, old-fashioned recipe, the kind of comfort food that felt like a hug, yet in the silence of the hotel room, it felt like a threat. I realized then that Douglas wasn't trying to scare me for fun; he was trying to save me from a curiosity that had already cost someone their identity.

Chapter 4

Hannah Mercado was a twenty-something parishioner with a rebellious streak and a habit of chewing on the end of her pencil. She had been assisting me with the filing, and she had seen the way I looked at the fourth chair.

"Rosemary hates it when people ask about the '54 gap," Hannah whispered as we walked toward the vestry. "But the records aren't all in the main office. Some of the real history is kept downstairs."

Using a heavy iron key Hannah had 'borrowed' from the caretaker, she sneaked me into the church basement. The air was thick with a damp, earthy musk and rotting cardboard. We navigated through stacks of old hymnals and broken pews until Hannah pointed to a locked steel trunk in the corner.

Inside, I found a leather-bound ledger, its pages yellowed and brittle. I flipped through the entries until I hit November 1954. There, written in a precise, archaic hand, was a document titled 'The Silent Covenant.' It was signed by the town elders of that era, including Rosemary’s father.

I read the lines carefully: *'To ensure the prosperity of Cedar Hollow and the shielding of its borders from ruin, a sacrifice of presence is required. One shall vanish so that all may thrive.'*

There was no mention of a ghost, but there was a list of dates—intervals of exactly seventy years. I felt a cold sweat break across my neck. I checked my watch. 1954 to 2024. This year. The timing was too precise to be a coincidence.

"What does it say?" Hannah asked, her voice echoing in the subterranean gloom.

I didn't tell her everything. I just told her it looked like an old land agreement. But as I closed the book, I noticed a smudge of yellow grease on the corner of the page. It smelled faintly of honey-butter. Someone had been reading this ledger recently.

Coming up in Part 3“The mystery of the appearing corn bread had driven me to a state of near-obsession. I couldn't sleep, and I…”