The Unmarked Tape in the 1988 VCR
Fiction. This is an original, made-up story: names, characters and events are invented, and any resemblance to real people or events is coincidental.
Part 2 of 5 · Chapters 3–4 of 10
Listen to Part 2 · 4 min
Chapter 3
"Who is this?" Mark asked, holding the TV screen's frozen image up to his sister.
Elena didn't even look up from her clipboard. She was in 'estate mode,' calculating the square footage of the bedrooms and checking the condition of the hardwood floors. She wanted this house sold by September. To her, the Oakhaven estate wasn't a sanctuary of memories; it was a monument to the childhood trauma of being ignored by a cold father.
"I don't know, Mark. Probably some old business partner," she said, her voice flat. She finally glanced at the screen, her eyes skimming over the vacant smile of the man in the charcoal suit. She didn't blink. She didn't gasp. She just sighed and stepped back, as if the image were something unpleasant she'd found on the bottom of her shoe.
"He's sitting right next to Dad. They look... close," Mark pressed. "Look at how Dad is leaning in. He's laughing. I've never seen him laugh like that."
Elena’s expression shifted. A flicker of irritation, or perhaps something deeper—fear—crossed her face. She snatched the remote and clicked the TV off, plunging the room into a sudden, oppressive gray.
"Stop this," she snapped. "Dad was a difficult man. He had secrets. That’s why we’re selling this place—to get away from the secrets. Burn the tape, Mark. Just burn it and let's finish the attic. We have a realtor coming on Friday, and I am not spending my vacation digging through a dead man's delusions."
She walked out of the room, the click of her heels echoing like a countdown. Mark stood in the silence, the ghost of that vacant smile still burned into his retinas. Elena didn't remember the man, but her reaction wasn't one of confusion. It was a desperate attempt to shut a door that Mark had just nudged open.
Chapter 4
The next morning, Mark returned to the attic, but he wasn't looking for boxes. He was looking for the gaps. If his father had gone to the trouble of labeling a tape 'Do Not Play,' there had to be more.
He spent hours digging through a cedar chest in the far corner, beneath a pile of moth-eaten wool blankets. At the bottom, he found a leather-bound photo album. It was small, weathered, and lacked a title. When he opened it, he felt a jolt of nausea.
The album was full of group photos—family vacations, Christmas mornings, neighborhood barbecues. But almost every single photo had been mutilated. Someone had taken a pair of scissors and meticulously cut out a specific person from every frame. There were jagged white holes where a man should have been.
Mark traced the edge of one cutout. In a photo from a 1985 trip to the lake, the hole was positioned exactly where the stranger from the tape would have stood. The cuts were precise, almost surgical. It wasn't an act of anger; it was an act of erasure. It was as if Arthur had tried to perform a lobotomy on his own history, removing a piece of his life until the wound healed over into a scar of silence.
As he flipped the pages, he found one photo that hadn't been cut. It was a candid shot of Arthur and the stranger standing back-to-back in front of the house. They looked identical—the same jawline, the same slope of the nose, the same height. The only difference was the expression. Arthur looked terrified, while the stranger wore that same vacant, haunting smile.
Mark felt the air in the attic grow thick and humid. He looked at the silver pocket watch on the table. It had stopped ticking entirely. The second hand was frozen, pointing straight up, as if waiting for a signal.
Coming up in Part 3“Mark drove three blocks over to the small, weathered bungalow of Mr. Henderson. Henderson had been Arthur's only remaining friend,…”