Mystery & Creepy

The Unmarked Tape in the 1988 VCR

Fiction. This is an original, made-up story: names, characters and events are invented, and any resemblance to real people or events is coincidental.

Part 3 of 5 · Chapters 5–6 of 10

Listen to Part 3 · 4 min

Chapter 5

Mark drove three blocks over to the small, weathered bungalow of Mr. Henderson. Henderson had been Arthur's only remaining friend, a retired actuary who spent his days tending to a garden of oversized hydrangeas.

When Henderson opened the door, the smell of peppermint and old paper drifted out. Mark didn't waste time. He held up his phone, showing a high-resolution screenshot of the stranger from the VHS tape.

The change in Henderson was instantaneous. The old man’s face didn't just pale; it seemed to collapse. He stepped back, his hand gripping the doorframe so hard his knuckles turned white. He didn't ask where Mark got the photo. He didn't ask who the man was.

"You shouldn't have looked for that, Mark," Henderson whispered, his voice trembling. "Some things are erased for a reason. Your father... he spent thirty years trying to build a wall around that memory. He did it to protect you. He did it to protect all of you."

"Protect us from what?" Mark asked, stepping forward. "He's my father's twin, isn't he? Why was he erased? Why is there a room in this house that feels like a tomb?"

Henderson’s eyes darted toward the Oakhaven house, visible in the distance. He looked exhausted, as if a burden he’d been carrying for decades had suddenly doubled in weight.

"The accident happened when they were nineteen," Henderson said softly. "A mistake. A moment of carelessness that changed everything. Arthur couldn't live with the guilt, and the other... the other couldn't live with the truth. They made a pact, but Arthur's version of a pact was to pretend the other half of his soul never existed. Go home, Mark. Burn the tape. Some ghosts are better left without a name."

Before Mark could ask another question, Henderson closed the door. The click of the lock sounded final, leaving Mark standing on the porch in the sweltering August heat.

Chapter 6

Mark returned to the living room and pushed the VHS tape back into the machine. He didn't watch the party this time; he scrubbed through the footage, frame by frame, searching for something Henderson had missed.

Near the end of the tape, the camera stopped panning. The person filming—likely his mother—had set the camera down on a sideboard. The shot was static, capturing the dinner table in a wide angle. For five minutes, the guests talked and laughed in a blur of background noise.

Then, the stranger did something.

He stood up and walked toward the camera. He didn't look at the other guests; he looked directly into the lens. His vacant smile vanished, replaced by a look of intense, focused urgency. He leaned in so close that his face blurred, his breath fogging the lens. He didn't shout; he whispered.

Mark turned the volume up to the maximum, straining to hear through the hiss of the old magnetic tape. The stranger's voice was a raspy mirror of Arthur's.

"August 14, 1988," the stranger whispered. "The heavy door. Beneath the floor. I am still waiting in the cellar."

Mark froze. August 14 was only three days away. He looked toward the hallway that led to the back of the house. At the end of that hall was the basement door. For his entire childhood, that door had been the one boundary he was never allowed to cross. Arthur had kept it locked with a heavy, industrial deadbolt, claiming the foundation was unstable and the air was toxic with mold.

He had believed it for twenty years. He had accepted the boundary because that was the rule of the house. But as Mark looked at the screen, he realized the stranger wasn't talking to the camera. He was talking to whoever found the tape. He was talking to Mark.

Coming up in Part 4“The deadbolt didn't stand a chance against a heavy-duty crowbar. With a screech of twisting metal, the lock snapped, and…”